A practical guide from Jeffrey White

Every Denver rental analysis comes down to two numbers: cap rate and cash flow. Cap rate tells you what the property earns relative to its price, before financing. Cash flow tells you what is left each month after the mortgage is paid. Run both, in this order, and you can screen almost any Denver rental in minutes — including spotting the deals that only look good in the listing.

Step 1: Start with the rent, not the price

Your analysis is only as honest as the rent figure inside it. Do not use the seller's asking rent or a hopeful projection. Build the rent from comparable properties: similar units, in the same area, rented recently. If the property is already tenanted, the actual lease is your starting point — checked against the market, because a below-market lease is real money you will not see until it renews, and an above-market claim is a red flag.

Everything downstream — cap rate, cash flow, your offer — inherits the quality of this one number. Slow down here.

Step 2: Build the full expense list

Amateur analysis dies in the expenses. A complete list for a Denver rental includes:

  • Property taxes and insurance
  • Vacancy allowance — units sit empty between tenants; budget for it every year
  • Repairs and maintenance reserve
  • Capital reserves for the big, boring items: roof, furnace, water heater
  • Property management, unless you will genuinely self-manage forever
  • Licensing and compliance costs — Denver requires a residential rental licence for long-term rentals
  • Utilities you will pay, HOA dues if any, and leasing costs

Rent minus these expenses is your net operating income (NOI). NOI is the engine of both headline numbers.

Step 3: Cap rate — the formula and a worked example

Cap rate = NOI ÷ purchase price. It ignores your loan entirely, which is why it is the cleanest way to compare one property against another.

Here is a worked example — illustrative round numbers only, not a real listing:

  • Price: $400,000. Rent: $2,200 a month, so $26,400 a year.
  • Vacancy at 5%: −$1,320. Effective income: $25,080.
  • Expenses: taxes $3,600, insurance $1,800, repairs reserve $1,800, capital reserve $1,800, management $2,000 — total $11,000.
  • NOI = $25,080 − $11,000 = $14,080. Cap rate = $14,080 ÷ $400,000 ≈ 3.5%.

Step 4: Cash flow — what is left after the mortgage

Cash flow = NOI − debt service. Same example: suppose the loan payment (principal and interest) is $1,900 a month, or $22,800 a year. Cash flow = $14,080 − $22,800 = −$8,720 a year, about −$727 a month.

Read that again, because it is the most useful lesson in this article: a property can show a respectable cap rate and still lose money every month once financing is real. At these example numbers, the deal does not work at this price — the price, the rent or the structure has to change. That is not a failure of the method. That is the method doing its job, before your money is involved. Run your own properties through the free tools on our investment calculators page and watch how sensitive the answer is to rent and price.

The checks beyond the two headline numbers

Cap rate and cash flow are the screen, not the whole decision. Also weigh: the condition of the roof, furnace and plumbing (a cheap property with dead systems is not cheap); whether the rental layout is legal and licensable; the neighbourhood's rental demand; and your exit — could you sell to another investor, refinance, or hold comfortably for a decade? Our companion piece on what a good cap rate means in Denver goes deeper on judging the rate itself, and the 1% rule article covers the quick screen many buyers start with.

Analysis mistakes that cost Denver buyers

  • Using the seller's rent figure and the seller's expense list, unverified.
  • Forgetting vacancy and capital reserves because "the place is in great shape."
  • Counting on appreciation to rescue negative cash flow.
  • Skipping the licensing and legality check on a basement or converted unit.
  • Analysing once, emotionally, after falling for the property — instead of on paper, first.

Analyse cold, in the same order, every time. The deals that survive honest math are the ones worth touring.

Step 5: Decide what the numbers are telling you

Analysis ends in one of three decisions. Buy it: both numbers work with conservative assumptions, the condition and licensing checks pass, and the property fits your plan for years, not months. Fix the deal: the property is right but the price is wrong — a lower price improves every figure at once, and a negative-cash-flow analysis is exactly the evidence a good negotiation is built on. Or the structure changes: a larger down payment, a legal second unit, a rent the market genuinely supports. Walk away: the numbers fail and no realistic change fixes them. Walking away costs you nothing but time; buying a failing deal costs you money every month you own it. Write your decision thresholds down before you tour — the time to decide what "good enough" means is before a property is standing in front of you looking charming.


Important: This article is for general educational purposes only and is not legal, tax, lending, insurance, financial, or investment advice. Rules, programs and market conditions change. Verify current information and consult appropriately licensed professionals before making decisions.

Discuss your real estate goals More articles