A practical guide from Jeffrey White

One property, two tax identities

Buy a duplex, live in one side and rent the other, and the IRS sees a personal residence and a rental property sharing one deed. The same is true, proportionally, when you rent bedrooms in a single-family home. Nearly every tax question in house hacking flows from that split: which expenses belong to the rental side, which to your personal side, and which must be divided between the two.

Get the framework right and house hacking offers a genuinely favourable tax profile: deductions and depreciation against rental income you would not have as a pure homeowner, alongside the homeowner benefits on your own share. Get it wrong — claiming the whole property as a rental, or ignoring the rental side entirely — and you invite either an audit problem or money left on the table.

How the split is calculated

Two allocation methods are common. For a multi-unit property, the split is often based on the relative size or value of the units — a duplex with two equal units is the easy case, fifty percent rental. For rented rooms in a single-family home, the split is typically based on the square footage rented compared with the whole home, or on the number of rooms.

Whichever method fits, use it consistently and write it down. The percentage you choose flows into everything: the share of mortgage interest and property taxes assigned to the rental, the depreciable basis of the building, and how shared repairs are divided. Your closing statement is the starting document — the purchase price is allocated between land, which never depreciates, and the building, which does.

Depreciation: the deduction you never write a cheque for

Depreciation lets you deduct a portion of the rental share of the building's value each year over twenty-seven and a half years — the standard recovery period for residential rental property. As an illustration with round numbers only: if the rental share of a building's value were $275,000, the annual depreciation deduction would be about $10,000, reducing taxable rental income without any cash leaving your account that year. (Figures are a generic example, not a property valuation.)

Two cautions ride along. First, only the building depreciates — the land allocation matters, and overstating the building share inflates deductions you will have to defend. Second, depreciation is not free money forever: when you sell, the depreciation you claimed (or could have claimed) is generally subject to recapture tax. It is a deferral and rate advantage, not an exemption, and it belongs in your long-term plan.

What is deductible on the rental side — and what is not

Against rental income you can generally deduct the rental share of mortgage interest, property taxes, insurance and utilities, plus wholly rental expenses: advertising, screening, repairs, supplies, licences and professional fees. Repairs that keep the property in working order are treated differently from improvements that add value or extend life — improvements are usually capitalised and depreciated instead. The line between the two is one of the most argued in rental taxes, so keep invoices and descriptions.

Just as important is what never becomes deductible: your mortgage principal is not an expense, your own living costs stay personal, and the personal share of shared bills remains personal. Run your scenarios with the investment calculators for the cash picture, but let a CPA who works with landlords translate it into the tax picture — the two are related, not identical.

Records to keep from day one

House hacking taxes reward tidy files. Keep the closing disclosure, the allocation worksheet showing your personal-rental split, every lease, a simple ledger separating rental income and expenses, and receipts for repairs and improvements with a note of which unit or area each served. Mileage for property trips, licence renewals and professional invoices all belong in the same folder.

Jeffrey White's investor clients hear the same advice at closing that they hear at tax time: bring a real estate CPA into the team in year one, not year five. With 118 closings and $71M in sales across the metro, Jeffrey can point you to the questions to ask — but the filing itself belongs to a licensed tax professional who knows your full situation.


Important: This article is for general educational purposes only and is not legal, tax, lending, insurance, financial, or investment advice. Rules, programs and market conditions change. Verify current information and consult appropriately licensed professionals before making decisions.

Discuss your real estate goals More articles